Week 7. From Structure to Speculation
What I did this week
Drafting the Framework Section
I wrote the first full draft of the Framework section, covering The 4-Layer Trust Framework and Framework in Application.
Renamed the four "pillars" to "layers," since the structure is really a stack, platform-enforced at the base, user-activated at the top, rather than four equal things sitting side by side. "Pillar" implied they all carried the same kind of weight, which wasn't accurate.
Built a bilateral tenant-landlord scenario, Joy and Kate, paired with a UI mockup for each layer, because the framework on its own stayed abstract. I wanted to show what all four layers actually look like from both sides of one real interaction, not just as four separate rules.
Created a practitioner-facing Application Guide table setting out the principle, design actions, and indicators for each layer, so a designer reading the paper would have something to actually act on, not just a description of the framework.
Brainstorming the Discussion Section
Following last week's meeting with Trevor, I spent this week developing the Discussion section topics. I have four candidate themes, all connected to the trust framework and the grey spaces between inclusion and exclusion.
Designing for User Manipulation (Soft Intent) (Trevor's idea): Intentionally leaving flexible interaction pathways open so users can adapt the platform to their own needs. For example, a tenant reaching out to another reviewer to ask for a reference about a landlord. Rather than locking down every interaction, the design acknowledges that users will bend the system in creative ways, and treats this as a resource rather than a threat.
Trust for Whom? The Exclusion Cost of Trust Mechanisms: Platform-enforced layers like Verification reduce scam anxiety, but identity checks and credit history requirements structurally filter out migrants, students, freelancers, and anyone without a formal credit record. The paradox: the very mechanisms that produce trust can become mechanisms of exclusion.
Who Performs the Labour of Trust?: As the framework moves toward user-activated layers, the quality of trust depends on user effort. Writing bios and micro-stories is self-presentation labour, and it favours those with writing skills, language fluency, and cultural capital. The burden of building trust is not distributed equally.
Delegated Trust-Work: Busy landlords may hand profile creation over to letting agents, meaning the platform does not remove intermediaries; intermediaries re-enter through the platform. This breaks a core assumption of the framework, that the author of a trust signal is the subject of that trust. A tenant believes they are reading the landlord, but they may be reading an agent's template.
What I am planning for next week
Supervisor Meeting (July 14)
I'll walk Trevor through the Framework draft and the four Discussion themes above, and see which direction he thinks is worth pushing further.
Drafting
Following the Gantt chart, I'll start drafting Methodology, Discussion & Limitations sections, building on the feedback comes out of the meeting.

Reflections
This week felt like two different modes of work. Drafting the Framework section was mostly about precision, getting the layering logic and the scenario to actually line up. The Discussion brainstorming was the opposite, looser and more speculative, and honestly the more enjoyable part. I'm curious to see which of the four themes Trevor thinks are worth pursuing further when we meet on the 14th.



Comments